Back to News
Pretended Sale and Homestead Exceptions in Texas Family Transfers: A Lender’s Guide
June 18, 2026
Texas law voids pretended sales of homestead property. Learn when title companies add pretended sale exceptions in family transfers, how to resolve them, and why lenders can’t close with this exception in place.
By Steve Manente, Attorney | DocsDirect
Key Takeaways
- Texas Constitution Article XVI, Section 50 voids any pretended sale of a homestead involving a disguised mortgage or condition of defeasance.
- Family transfers, parents selling to children, in particular, are the transaction type most likely to trigger a pretended sale or homestead exception on a lender’s title policy.
- A loan closed with this exception in place is unsalable on the secondary market and leaves the lender holding uninsured title risk.
- Title companies will sometimes remove the exception given an affidavit of vacatur, proof of the seller’s new residence, confirmation of no leaseback, and an appraisal-supported sales price.
- If the exception cannot be removed, the loan should not close.
What Is a Pretended Sale Under Texas Law?
A pretended sale is a transaction structured to look like an outright conveyance of homestead property, but that is actually intended to create a lien or security interest outside what the Texas Constitution permits.
Under Texas Constitution, Article XVI, Section 50, any pretended sale of a homestead involving a condition of defeasance, including a conveyance intended as a mortgage, is void. Courts look past the form of the transaction to the parties’ actual intent. In Johnson v. Cherry, 726 S.W.2d 4 (Tex. 1987), the Texas Supreme Court held that the parties’ intention, not merely the structure of the deed, determines whether a sale is genuine or pretended.
Courts evaluating intent typically examine:
- Whether the conveyance was absolute
- Whether purchase money was actually paid
- Whether pre-existing debts were involved
If a transaction is found to be a pretended sale intended to create a lien outside permitted constitutional categories, the lien has no legal effect. Anglin v. Cisco Mortgage Loan Co., 135 Tex. 188, 141 S.W.2d 935 (1940); Toler v. Fertitta, 67 S.W.2d 229 (Tex. Comm’n App. 1934).
How Does Texas Property Code Section 41.006 Expand This Risk?
Texas Property Code Section 41.006 creates an additional, broader risk. A homestead sale at a below-market price combined with a leaseback to the seller (where lease payments exceed fair rental value) is deemed a loan by operation of law. Any deed executed in that scenario is void, and no lien attaches to the property at all.
What this means for lenders: the mortgage would be entirely unenforceable, not merely subject to a coverage gap.
When Does a Pretended Sale Exception Typically Arise?
Watch for these fact patterns at origination, before the title commitment is even ordered:
- The seller and buyer are related (parent/child, siblings, spouses, or other family members)
- The seller retains possession of the property after closing, permanently or for an extended period
- The seller is not purchasing a replacement Texas homestead
- The seller is moving to a rental, assisted living facility, or out of state, but has not done so by closing
- The sales price is at or below market value, paired with a lease or informal occupancy arrangement
- Lease payments appear disproportionate to fair market rental value
Any one of these factors should prompt an immediate inquiry to the title company about what exceptions will appear on the final lender’s policy.
What Does a Pretended Sale Exception on a Title Policy Actually Mean?
The exception tells the lender directly: if this transaction is later challenged as a pretended sale, the title company will not cover the loss.
This is not a minor technicality. It excludes coverage in exactly the scenario most likely to occur in a family transfer. A loan should not close with this exception on the final lender’s title policy, as secondary market investors require clean title coverage, and the lender would otherwise hold uninsured risk indefinitely.
How Can Lenders Resolve a Pretended Sale Exception Before Closing?
Title companies will sometimes remove the exception given sufficient evidence that the sellers are genuinely vacating the property. Effective documentation includes:
1. Seller Affidavit of Vacatur A sworn affidavit from the sellers confirming they are vacating the property, retain no homestead interest, and acknowledge the sale is outright with no right of return or continued occupancy.
2. Evidence of the Sellers’ New Residence Acceptable proof typically includes a fully executed lease, a signed assisted living or continuing care admission agreement, evidence of a purchase contract or closing on a new residence, or similar documentation of an established or in-process new residence.
3. Confirmation of No Leaseback Written confirmation that no lease, license, or informal arrangement allows the sellers to remain in the property post-closing. Even brief, rent-free occupancy can create pretended sale risk. If any post-closing occupancy by the sellers is contemplated, the transaction should not proceed.
4. Appraisal-Supported Sales Price The sales price should be at or near fair market value, supported by an appraisal. A below-market price is a significant red flag that strengthens a pretended sale argument.
What If the Title Company Won’t Remove the Exception?
If the title company of record refuses to remove the exception despite full documentation:
- Engage a second or third title company with the same documentation to see whether another underwriter will insure the transaction cleanly
- Consult legal counsel regarding the specific facts and available curative measures
- Do not close the loan with the exception in place as a workaround, regardless of borrower pressure or time constraints
Compliance Checklist for Loan Officers and Underwriters
| Step | Action |
|---|---|
| 1 | Flag family-relationship transactions at origination. Don't wait for the title commitment |
| 2 | Order the title commitment promptly and review specifically for pretended sale or homestead exceptions |
| 3 | Do not clear-to-close if the exception appears on the commitment or marked-up policy |
| 4 | Request an affidavit of vacatur and evidence of new residence; submit to the title company for exception removal |
| 6 | Verify the sales price is at or near fair market value, supported by appraisal |
| 7 | If the exception cannot be removed, escalate to compliance or legal counsel and do not close |
| 8 | Document the file: steps taken, title company communications, and the basis for the final decision |
The Bottom Line
Texas law provides extraordinary, broadly-applied protections to homestead claimants. A family transfer where the seller remains in the property or hasn’t yet moved to a replacement homestead is one of the most vulnerable transaction types in Texas mortgage lending.
A title exception is the title company telling the lender the risk is real. Resolve it before closing, or decline the loan. A loan closed with an unresolved pretended sale exception is not a completed loan; it is a liability.
Frequently Asked Questions
A pretended sale is a transaction structured as an outright conveyance of homestead property but actually intended to create a lien or mortgage outside the categories permitted by the Texas Constitution. Under Article XVI, Section 50, such transactions are void, regardless of the form the deed takes.
Family transfers — especially parent-to-child sales — often involve the seller remaining in possession, a below-market price, or an informal arrangement for continued occupancy. These are exactly the fact patterns Texas courts examine when determining whether a sale is genuine or a disguised mortgage.
This is not advisable. The exception means the title company will not cover losses if the transaction is later challenged as a pretended sale. Loans with this exception are typically unsalable on the secondary market and leave the lender with uninsured risk.
Title companies have removed the exception based on a seller affidavit of vacatur, evidence of the seller’s new residence, written confirmation of no leaseback arrangement, and an appraisal supporting a fair-market sales price.
Not necessarily, but Texas tracks whether a property has ever had a Section 50(a)(6) loan against it. A later refinance may still be treated as a home equity loan even if the new transaction looks like a standard refinance, depending on lien history and structure.
Texas Property Code Section 41.006, this fact pattern is deemed a loan by operation of law. Any deed executed in connection with it is void, and no lien attaches to the property — meaning the lender’s mortgage would be unenforceable.
Family transfers carry elevated legal risk under Texas homestead law. Schwartz Manente PLLC helps lenders identify pretended sale risk early, resolve title exceptions, and close family transfer loans with confidence.
Contact us
